Should I keep my car?

Pick your car and type its mileage. You get the jobs its factory schedule calls for over the next 30,000 miles with what each costs at a shop, what a car like yours costs to maintain per mile at its age, and a straight read on keeping it or replacing it.

The car picker and your own result need JavaScript. Three worked examples, the cost-per-mile table and the method are below.

Keep it or replace it?

What tips it toward replacing

  • A repair quote that is large next to what the car is worth - get the quote in writing first.
  • Rust on the frame, subframe or brake lines, or a safety problem that cannot be fixed for sensible money.
  • You need reliability it no longer gives you: breakdowns, missed work, a car you do not trust on a long trip.

What tips it toward keeping

  • The jobs ahead are the routine ones in the list above, and it passes inspection.
  • No repair quote on the table, no leaks or warning lights you have been ignoring.
  • You are willing to keep up with the schedule - reminders make that the easy part.

How to use it

  1. Choose the make, model and model year.
  2. Type the odometer reading.
  3. Read the jobs coming up in the next 30,000 miles, each with its shop and DIY price, and the total.
  4. Check the cost per mile for a car like yours at its age, and the keep-or-replace read.
  5. Open the True Cost to Own calculator to put your car next to a replacement with your own prices.

Worked examples (as of 2026)

2010 Toyota Corolla at 200,000 miles

Maintenance at this age: 6.3 cents a mile ($760 a year - our year-12 estimate, the last year we publish).

Keeping it: our estimates stop at year 12, where a Toyota Corolla costs about $760 a year in maintenance and typical repairs (6.3 cents a mile). Your car is further along than that, so this is the closest figure we publish, not one for its age.

The scheduled jobs we can price for the next 30,000 miles come to $335-$550 at a shop - $11-$18 a month if you drive 12,000 miles a year.

A new Toyota Corolla costs about $192 in its first year by the same table - $568 a year less to maintain. Replacing saves money only if the value the newer car loses each year, plus any extra insurance and loan interest, comes to less than that saving plus the repairs you would avoid. The True Cost calculator works that out with your numbers.

Coming up between 200,000 and 230,000 miles

JobDue atShop, eachDIY, eachShop total
Tire rotation200,000, 205,000, 210,000, 215,000, 220,000, 225,000 miNo price in our data--
Oil & filter change200,000, 210,000, 220,000 mi$60-$90$25-$40$180-$270
Coolant flush & refill200,000 mi$80-$150$20-$40$80-$150
Replace cabin air filter210,000 mi$40-$70$15-$25$40-$70
Replace engine air filter210,000 mi$35-$60$15-$25$35-$60

Priced jobs: $335-$550 at a shop, $125-$210 if you do them yourself.

No price in our Toyota Corolla cost table for: tire rotation. We leave those out of the total rather than guess.

Due before your current mileage, and not again in the next 30,000 miles. If there is no record of them, they are due now:

  • Replace iridium spark plugs (due at 120,000 mi): $120-$200 at a shop

Also checked at these visits (no separate price): inspect fluid levels, check wiper blades, visually inspect brake linings/pads, reset Maintenance Required indicator, inspect water pump, check PCV valve, inspect all suspension components, inspect coolant condition, check battery charge & terminals.

One row that applies only under special conditions is left out (towing, heavy loads, extensive idling, an oil grade other than the one specified and the like). If that is how you drive, see the schedule page.

Jobs: the 2010 Toyota Corolla factory schedule on our schedule page. Prices and yearly estimates: our Toyota Corolla maintenance cost by year page - ServiceSage Auto estimates anchored to RepairPal and CarEdge averages at about 12,000 miles a year, not quotes.

2010 Toyota Corolla maintenance schedule | Toyota Corolla maintenance cost by year | Compare keeping it with a replacement

2012 Honda Civic at 150,000 miles

Maintenance at this age: 8.2 cents a mile ($985 a year - our year-12 estimate, the last year we publish).

Keeping it: our estimates stop at year 12, where a Honda Civic costs about $985 a year in maintenance and typical repairs (8.2 cents a mile). Your car is further along than that, so this is the closest figure we publish, not one for its age.

The scheduled jobs we can price for the next 30,000 miles come to $240-$380 at a shop, plus the jobs your car's maintenance reminder calls for (listed below) - $8-$13 a month if you drive 12,000 miles a year.

A new Honda Civic costs about $234 in its first year by the same table - $751 a year less to maintain. Replacing saves money only if the value the newer car loses each year, plus any extra insurance and loan interest, comes to less than that saving plus the repairs you would avoid. The True Cost calculator works that out with your numbers.

Coming up between 150,000 and 180,000 miles

JobDue atShop, eachDIY, eachShop total
Oil & filter changeabout 150,000, 157,500, 165,000, 172,500 mi$60-$95$25-$45$240-$380

Priced jobs: $240-$380 at a shop, $100-$180 if you do them yourself, plus the jobs your car's maintenance reminder calls for (listed below).

No fixed mileage - the car's maintenance reminder decides:

  • Minder Code 1 (add-on): Tire rotation & balance (no price in our data)
  • Minder Code 2 (no fixed mileage under normal driving): Replace engine air filter ($35-$60); Replace dust/pollen filter (cabin) ($40-$70)
  • Minder Code 3 (no fixed mileage under normal driving): Replace transmission fluid (automatic) (no price in our data)
  • Minder Code 5 (no fixed mileage under normal driving): Coolant replacement ($110-$170)
  • Minder Code 4 (no fixed mileage under normal driving): Replace iridium spark plugs ($140-$220)

Also checked at these visits (no separate price): inspect brake system, inspect steering & suspension, inspect fuel lines & hoses, inspect fluid levels.

One row that applies only under special conditions is left out (towing, heavy loads, extensive idling, an oil grade other than the one specified and the like). If that is how you drive, see the schedule page.

Jobs: the 2012 Honda Civic factory schedule on our schedule page. Prices and yearly estimates: our Honda Civic maintenance cost by year page - ServiceSage Auto estimates anchored to RepairPal and CarEdge averages at about 12,000 miles a year, not quotes.

2012 Honda Civic maintenance schedule | Honda Civic maintenance cost by year | Compare keeping it with a replacement

2012 Toyota Camry at 150,000 miles

Maintenance at this age: 6.6 cents a mile ($790 a year - our year-12 estimate, the last year we publish).

Keeping it: our estimates stop at year 12, where a Toyota Camry costs about $790 a year in maintenance and typical repairs (6.6 cents a mile). Your car is further along than that, so this is the closest figure we publish, not one for its age.

The scheduled jobs we can price for the next 30,000 miles come to $335-$545 at a shop - $11-$18 a month if you drive 12,000 miles a year.

A new Toyota Camry costs about $190 in its first year by the same table - $600 a year less to maintain. Replacing saves money only if the value the newer car loses each year, plus any extra insurance and loan interest, comes to less than that saving plus the repairs you would avoid. The True Cost calculator works that out with your numbers.

Coming up between 150,000 and 180,000 miles

JobDue atShop, eachDIY, eachShop total
Tire rotation150,000, 155,000, 160,000, 165,000, 170,000, 175,000 miNo price in our data--
Oil & filter change (0W-20 full synthetic)150,000, 160,000, 170,000 mi$70-$110$30-$55$210-$330
Replace cabin air filterabout 150,000, 165,000 mi$40-$70$12-$25$80-$140
Replace engine air filter150,000 mi$45-$75$18-$35$45-$75

Priced jobs: $335-$545 at a shop, $132-$250 if you do them yourself.

No price in our Toyota Camry cost table for: tire rotation. We leave those out of the total rather than guess.

Due before your current mileage, and not again in the next 30,000 miles. If there is no record of them, they are due now:

  • Coolant flush (Toyota Super Long Life, pink) (due at 100,000 mi): $90-$160 at a shop
  • Replace brake fluid (due at 120,000 mi): no price in our data
  • Replace iridium spark plugs (due at 120,000 mi): $170-$340 at a shop

Also checked at these visits (no separate price): inspect fluid levels, visual brake inspection, inspect wiper blades and lights, inspect brake pads and rotors, inspect belts and hoses, inspect coolant condition, inspect drivetrain and suspension, inspect the automatic transmission for leaks.

Jobs: the 2012 Toyota Camry factory schedule on our schedule page. Prices and yearly estimates: our Toyota Camry maintenance cost by year page - ServiceSage Auto estimates anchored to RepairPal and CarEdge averages at about 12,000 miles a year, not quotes.

2012 Toyota Camry maintenance schedule | Toyota Camry maintenance cost by year | Compare keeping it with a replacement

Maintenance cost per mile by age

From our cost-by-year tables, at about 12,000 miles a year.

ModelYear 1Year 3Year 5Year 8Year 10Year 12
Toyota Corolla1.6 cents ($192/yr)2.3 cents ($271/yr)3.4 cents ($407/yr)5.1 cents ($608/yr)5.5 cents ($655/yr)6.3 cents ($760/yr)
Honda Civic2.0 cents ($234/yr)2.8 cents ($338/yr)4.3 cents ($516/yr)6.5 cents ($779/yr)7.0 cents ($841/yr)8.2 cents ($985/yr)
Toyota Camry1.6 cents ($190/yr)2.7 cents ($320/yr)4.8 cents ($580/yr)4.8 cents ($570/yr)5.7 cents ($680/yr)6.6 cents ($790/yr)

How we work it out

The jobs come from the factory maintenance schedule we publish for that model year. Every due point between your mileage and 30,000 miles past it is listed; on a Honda, a Maintenance Minder B service replaces the A service it would otherwise double up with, and Minder codes with no fixed mileage are listed separately. Severe-duty rows are left out.

Each job is priced from the common-repair table on the model's maintenance cost by year page. A job that table has no row for, and every inspection, is shown without a price; it is not counted in the total.

The yearly estimate and cost per mile come from the same page's year-by-year table, built for about 12,000 miles a year. Those tables stop at year 12; a car past that is shown the year-12 figure, labelled as such.

Cars covered

True Cost to Own calculator | Maintenance cost calculator | Get reminders before each job is due

Frequently asked questions

How do I decide whether to keep my car or replace it?

Compare what keeping it will cost over the next couple of years - maintenance, the repairs it is likely to need, fuel and insurance - with what a replacement costs over the same time: the value it loses, any loan interest, and its own running costs. Maintenance alone rarely decides it; a big repair quote, rust or reliability you can no longer count on usually does. This page prices the scheduled maintenance for your car's next 30,000 miles and gives our yearly estimate for its age; the True Cost to Own calculator puts your car and a replacement side by side.

Is a 2010 Toyota Corolla with 200,000 miles worth keeping?

By its factory schedule, the next 30,000 miles from 200,000 bring oil & filter change (3 times), coolant flush & refill (once), cabin air filter (once), engine air filter (once): $335-$550 at a shop by our Toyota Corolla cost table. Add tire rotation, which that table does not price. No record of the iridium spark plugs due at 120,000 miles? Add $120-$200. Our yearly estimate for a Toyota Corolla tops out at $760 in year 12 (6.3 cents a mile), and a 2010 is past that. Those are routine costs. Whether it is worth keeping comes down to its condition - rust, leaks, the transmission - and any repair quote you have; the True Cost to Own calculator compares it with a replacement.

When should I replace my Honda Civic?

Honda does not publish an age or mileage at which to replace a Civic, and neither do we. By our Civic cost table, maintenance and typical repairs rise from about $234 in year 1 to about $985 in year 12. Take a 2012 Honda Civic at 150,000 miles. By its factory schedule, the next 30,000 miles from 150,000 bring oil & filter change (4 times): $240-$380 at a shop by our Honda Civic cost table. The Maintenance Minder decides when the rest come due: engine air filter $35-$60, dust/pollen filter $40-$70, coolant replacement $110-$170, iridium spark plugs $140-$220. Our yearly estimate for a Honda Civic tops out at $985 in year 12 (8.2 cents a mile), and a 2012 is past that. Those are routine costs. Whether it is worth keeping comes down to its condition - rust, leaks, the transmission - and any repair quote you have; the True Cost to Own calculator compares it with a replacement.

How much does a 2012 Toyota Camry with 150,000 miles cost to keep running?

By its factory schedule, the next 30,000 miles from 150,000 bring oil & filter change (3 times), cabin air filter (2 times), engine air filter (once): $335-$545 at a shop by our Toyota Camry cost table. Add tire rotation, which that table does not price. No record of the coolant flush due at 100,000 miles? Add $90-$160. No record of the iridium spark plugs due at 120,000 miles? Add $170-$340. Our yearly estimate for a Toyota Camry tops out at $790 in year 12 (6.6 cents a mile), and a 2012 is past that. Those are routine costs. Whether it is worth keeping comes down to its condition - rust, leaks, the transmission - and any repair quote you have; the True Cost to Own calculator compares it with a replacement.

How much does a car cost to maintain per mile as it gets older?

By our cost-by-year tables, at about 12,000 miles a year: Toyota Corolla 1.6 cents in year 1 to 6.3 cents in year 12; Honda Civic 2.0 cents in year 1 to 8.2 cents in year 12; Toyota Camry 1.6 cents in year 1 to 6.6 cents in year 12. The rise comes from bigger scheduled jobs (spark plugs, coolant, transmission fluid) and from wear items and repairs that a young car does not need yet.

Where do the numbers on this page come from?

The jobs come from the factory maintenance schedule we publish for that model year. Every due point between your mileage and 30,000 miles past it is listed; on a Honda, a Maintenance Minder B service replaces the A service it would otherwise double up with, and Minder codes with no fixed mileage are listed separately. Severe-duty rows are left out. Each job is priced from the common-repair table on the model's maintenance cost by year page. A job that table has no row for, and every inspection, is shown without a price; it is not counted in the total. The yearly estimate and cost per mile come from the same page's year-by-year table, built for about 12,000 miles a year. Those tables stop at year 12; a car past that is shown the year-12 figure, labelled as such. The cost tables are ServiceSage Auto estimates anchored to RepairPal and CarEdge averages, not quotes; each cost page explains how they were built.

Why do some jobs show no price?

Because the model's cost table has no row for them - tire rotation is the usual one - or because they are inspections done during the visit. We show the job and leave it out of the total rather than fill the gap with a guess. Your shop can quote it.